Evaluating Exposure to Impacts

The ART Program uses a stepwise approach for sea level rise and flood exposure analysis that saves time and resources, and pinpoints the most pressing issues and areas that need to be explored further.

ExampleExposureMap

Example sea level rise inundation map. Credit: NOAA Sea Level Rise Viewer

An exposure analysis identifies which assets will be exposed to a specific climate impact or hazard. It provides insight into the amount of possible damage or loss that could occur, for example to different types of land uses such as housing or commercial properties, and to the community members who rely on these uses.

While an exposure analysis is a necessary part of an adaptation planning assessment, it does not capture the nuances of how a climate impact or hazard may or may not affect the assets being evaluated.

ExampleExposureTable

Example exposure table. Photo credit: BCDC

For example, if homes have been elevated, they may be less at risk than they appear on an exposure map. However, even homes that are not directly exposed to flooding may be vulnerable if the key access roads or services (e.g., power, emergency response) that they rely on are affected. An exposure analysis is only one component of a robust assessment and needs to be completed in parallel with gathering information about asset existing conditions, and the causes and components of vulnerability and consequences. The ART Program has developed a set of assessment questions to systematically and efficiently gather this information for a wide variety of assets.

Exposure Analysis in ART

Evaluation of exposure to climate impacts is based on the selected scenarios. Experts with local knowledge of the project area, the shoreline, flood control and stormwater assets ground truth the exposure analysis findings which are summarized into maps, tables, charts and statements.

The ART approach to analyzing exposure is a stepwise process that begins with reviewing available data and information for each climate impact or hazard being addressed. For some impacts or hazards, such as flooding from current storms or future sea level rise, ready-to-use mapping tools may be available. For other impacts that are not as well-studied or understood (e.g., salinity intrusion due to sea level rise or precipitation patterns) reliable information may not be readily available.

The ART approach to exposure analysis is a stepwise process that begins with reviewing available data and information for each climate impact being addressed. For some impacts, such as inundation from higher high tides due to sea level rise, ready-to-use mapping tools may be available to evaluate asset exposure. For other climate impacts that are not as well-studied or understood (e.g., salinity intrusion due to sea level rise or changes in precipitation patterns) reliable information may not be readily available, and an exposure analysis cannot be done.

Readily available data and information is then used to evaluate exposure. For sea level rise the exposure analysis can answer the following questions:

  • Will the asset in question get wet?
  • If so, during what storm event, or with what amount of sea level rise?
  • And, to what extent or depth with the flooding occur?

Once the exposure analysis is completed the summarized findings need to be reviewed by those with local knowledge and experience. This will help pinpoint the locations where regional or broader mapping has not adequately characterized local conditions and where additional studies, field verification, remapping or re-analysis is needed.

Total Water Level Analysis

To evaluate coastal flooding, the ART Program uses a total water level approach in which each water level represents a range of possible future scenarios.

ExampleTotal WaterLevel Analysis map

Photo credit: BCDC

This approach reduces the total number of maps needed because each map represents a different, unique combination of sea level rise and storm events (extreme tides due to storm surge) that can result in current or future flooding. Extreme tides are the maximum high tide level that has occurred over a specific return period (recurrence interval) that correlates to a specific occurrence probability. For example a 100-year extreme tide has a return period of 100 years, and therefore a 1% chance of occurring in any given year.

Shoreline Overtopping Potential

Overtopping potential refers to the condition where a specific water level exceeds the elevation of the existing shoreline, potentially causing flooding of inland, low-lying areas.

The ART Program has analyzed the overtopping potential in a number of different projects to identify where the shoreline might not be high enough to control inland flooding that could occur from a storm event or due to sea level rise. These analyses do not account for the physics of wave setup and runup, the condition of the shoreline asset, or the potential for the asset to fail due to scour, undermining or a breach after the initial overtopping occurs. As such, the overtopping potential served as a screening tool to help direct resources to specific shoreline areas where further study is needed to understand the risks.

Links:

 

For more information:

  • Eliza Berry
  • Eliza.Berry@bcdc.ca.gov
  • 415-352-3660